Sunday, December 13, 2015

List of Scotch Whiskies With or Without Caramel Coloring

When attending scotch whisky tastings, you'll often see the presenter hold up the glass and implore the crowd to look at the deeply rich color of the liquid. Considering that most scotch whisky has dye in it (caramel coloring, also known as E150a), there is often no point in looking at it. If you, like me, want to appreciate the unique appearance that a whisky has been imparted by the infinite combinations of barrels, temperatures and settings of the distillery, you can use the below list to determine what to buy.

This list is a work in progress, so let me know if you see any distilleries that are missing and I'll be happy to add them.

DistilleryExpressionIs Caramel Coloring Added?
Aberfeldy12 YearYes
Aberlour10 YearYes
Aberlour18 YearYes
Ardbeg10 YearNo
ArdbegCorryvreckanNo
ArdbegUigeadailNo
Ardmore12 Year Port Wood FinishYes
Auchentoshan12 YearYes
Auchentoshan18 YearYes
BalvenieCuban Selection 14 YearYes
BalvenieDouble Wood 12 YearYes
BalveniePort-Wood 21 YearYes
BenRiach12 YearYes
BenRiach15 YearYes
BenRiachAlbariza 18 YearNo
BenRiachDunder 18 YearNo
BenRiachLatada 18 YearNo
BenRiachPedro Jimenez 15 YearYes
BenromachOrganicNo
BenromachPeat SmokeYes
BenromachTraditional Yes
Bladnoch19 YearYes
Bowmore12 YearYes
Bowmore18 YearYes
BruichladdichHart Brothers 20 YearNo
Bunahabhain12 YearYes
Bunahabhain18 YearYes
Caol Ila12 YearYes
Caol Ila18 YearYes
Caol Ila25 YearNo
Cardhu12 YearYes
Cardhu15 YearNo
Cardhu18 YearYes
CardhuSpecial Cask ReserveYes
Clynelish14 YearYes
Cragganmore12 YearYes
Dalmore12 YearYes
Dalmore15 YearYes
Dalmore18 yearYes
DalmoreCigar Malt ReserveYes
DalmoreKing Alexander IIINo
Dalwhinnie15 YearYes
Deanston12 YearYes
DufftownSingleton 12 YearYes
Edradour10 YearYes
FettercairnFiorYes
Glen Deveron10 YearYes
Glen Elgin12 YearYes
Glen Garioch12 YearYes
Glen GariochFounders ReserveYes
Glen Grant10 YearYes
Glen Moray10 YearNo
Glen Moray12 YearYes
Glen Moray16 YearYes
Glen MorayPeatedYes
Glen Scotia10 YearNo
Glen Scotia12 YearNo
Glen Scotia16 YearNo
Glen Scotia21 YearNo
Glen Spey12 YearYes
Glencadam10 YearNo
Glencadam15 YearNo
Glencadam21 YearNo
Glendronach12 YearNo
GlendronachAllardice 18 YearNo
GlendronachHielan 8 YearNo
GlendronachParliament 21 YearNo
GlendronachPeatedNo
GlendronachTawny Port 18 YearNo
Glenfarclas10 YearYes
Glenfarclas105 Cask StrengthYes
Glenfarclas15 YearNo
Glenfarclas17 YearNo
Glenfarclas21 YearYes
Glenfarclas25 YearYes
GlenfarclasHeritageYes
Glenfiddich12 YearYes
Glenfiddich18 YearYes
GlenfiddichRich Oak 14 YearNo
GlenfiddichSmall Batch Reserve 18 YearNo
GlenfiddichSolera Reserve 15 YearYes
GlenglassaughEvolutionNo
GlenglassaughRevivalNo
GlenglassaughTorfaNo
Glengoyne12 YearNo
Glengoyne15 YearYes
Glengoyne21 YearYes
Glenkinchie12 YearYes
Glenlivet12 YearYes
Glenlivet21 YearYes
GlenlivetFrench Oak Reserve 15 YearYes
Glenmorangie10 YearYes
Glenmorangie18 YearYes
Glenmorangie25 YearYes
GlenmorangieLasanta 12 YearYes
GlenmorangieNectar D'Or 12 YearYes
GlenmorangieQuinta Ruban 12 YearYes
GlenmorangieSignetYes
GlenrothesAlba ReserveYes
GlenrothesRobur ReserveYes
GlenrothesSherry Cask ReserveNo
Glenturret10 YearYes
Glenturret8 YearYes
Isle of Jura10 YearYes
Isle of Jura16 YearYes
Isle of JuraProphecyYes
Isle of JuraSuperstitionYes
Knockando12 YearYes
Lagavulin16 YearYes
Laphroig10 YearYes
Laphroig18 YearYes
LaphroigQuarter CaskYes
LaphroigSelectYes
Longmorn16 YearYes
Macallan10 YearNo
Macallan12 YearNo
Macallan15 YearNo
Macallan17 YearNo
Macallan18 YearNo
Macallan21 YearNo
Macallan25 YearNo
Macallan30 YearNo
Oban14 YearYes
Old Pulteney12 YearYes
Royal Lochnagar12 YearYes
Scapa16 YearYes
Speyburn10 YearYes
Springbank10 YearYes
Springbank15 YearNo
Talisker10 YearYes
Talisker18 YearYes
Talisker57 Degrees NorthYes
TaliskerPort RuigheYes
TaliskerSkyeNo
TaliskerStormYes
Tamdhu10 YearNo
TamdhuTamdhuYes
Tobermory15 YearNo
Tomatin12 YearYes
Tomatin15 YearYes
Tomatin18 YearYes
TomatinCu BocanNo
TomatinLegacyYes
Tomintoul10 YearYes
Tomintoul16 YearYes
TomintoulPeaty TangYes

29 comments:

  1. You bloody Yanks should mind your own business! The reason we do it is to satisfy your unsophisticated American palate. I'll give you the ole Glaswegian kiss if you ever show up on the my side of Lanarkshire.

    Yours in Braveheart,

    Angus

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Funny how American whiskey doesn't need coloring. What is it that Americans know that Scots just can't quite figure out about distilling? Maybe it's something to do with being able to successfully kick out the English. Cry some more, please.

      Delete
    2. Temperature. No, seriously. What does America do to make dark whiskey without coloring? Literally, it's just hotter in America, meaning the whiskey from America interacts more with the wood in the barrel than the whisky from Scotland when aging for the same amount of time. There's actually more to it than that, but on another note:

      By American law, not only can you use E150A in whiskey, but you can ALSO use E150B (banned in Scotch whisky). E150B is a caramel coloring of slightly lower quality that has a slight flavor of its own (while E150A is considered tasteless). The only term (by law) that requires no artificial color be added if you want to use it is "straight," as in "straight bourbon whiskey" or "straight whiskey."

      So, it's not as cut and dry as you might think. Do a little more research on it all and you might be surprised all that you unearth.

      Delete
    3. This list is absolute bullshit !!!!!!

      Delete
    4. Yes, this list very inaccurate and misleading.

      Delete
    5. By American law Bourbon can NOT have any additives legally including coloring agents. The reason American whiskys are darker is because they use new charred barrels whereas Scotch uses used barrels that have already imparted most of their color into a different spirit. It has nothing to do with temperature. And the term "Straight" refers to it being aged a minimum of two years in new oak barrels, except corn whisky which can use used barrels. Do some research yourself. Also this list is bullshit and highly inaccurate

      Delete
  2. Thank you for this list. After finding out Laphroaig was artificially colored, I decided to try out a naturally colored Islay malt. Your list helped make the task considerably shorter. To hell with E150a. And to Angus Campbell, bite your tongue boy or we'll keep our bourbon casks.

    Scott

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This list is VERY wrong. Not even close, really.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dalmore King Alexander III ingredients from distillery:
    Ingredients
    Demineralised water, alcohol, caramel E 150a(.0 / 1%).

    DO NOT BELIEVE THIS LIST JUST BECAUSE IT'S ON THE INTERNET

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Can you provide the link? I'll make the correction if this is accurate

      Delete
  5. All this does is 1 highlight Tasting notes colour. Taste is it Caramel yet E150A is said to be tastless Glenfarclas for years has been dark and carmelized in taste. So are the distillaries being upfront with the ir consumers? Who does the QC on these products or is it self regulated and prone to deceit?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks this list. It is a good starting point but I think we will see more yes in the future. We have to talk about it and press distilleries to not to use any additional thing instead of pure water.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Chivas Regal 12 years, also adds caramel. If it´s so good. Why do they need to add anything else ,than scotch?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank for this! This is great!!
    Also, famous grouse also has e150, just had an allergic reaction so that’s that.
    Definitely saving your list in my favs!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Famous grouse also has e150, just had an allergic reaction to it...

    ReplyDelete
  10. I believe this list to be incomplete, and possibly too out of date to be currently accurate.
    It has been helpful in selecting brands, though many are missing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. How do we know this list is accurate? There's a lot of whisky misssin'. Adding color can be innocent - so the whisky looks consistent to uninformed customers - or it can be nefarious - to make a whisky look older and richer than it is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We don’t know shit. This is the internet.

      Delete
  12. Hmm...A real eye opener to be sure. That's marketing for you. Regardless, it's all about your pallet preference and naysayers be damned! I will still drink my Cardhu 12, Dalmore 15 & Lagavulin 16 with bliss!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Glengoyne 21y state on the label of the bottle natural colour so that´s wrong in the list

    ReplyDelete
  14. This list is flawed and was already out-of-date by at least 5 years when it was published. For instance, Bunahabhain USED to use e150a caramel coloring but stopped doing that in 2010 and has sold only naturally-colored scotch since then.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Bloody Scottish wankers

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi There,

    Thank you for sharing the knowledgeable blog with us I hope that you will post many

    more blog with us:-

    Home - An incredibly sleek bottle of Glenfarclas, which has seen a jaw-dropping 50 years of ageing! It spent its half a century of maturation in Spanish oak sherry casks, left to rest in cool dunnage warehouses. Just 146 bottles were produced. The sherried single malt is presented in a Glencairn Crystal decanter, hand-decorated in copper complete [...]
    E-Mail : info@whiskyhunterdrinkss.com
    Click here for more information:- more info

    ReplyDelete
  17. The bottom line is the majority of scotch whiskey uses artificial coloring which is pathetic and misleading and we Americans use NO coloring at all in our bourbon whiskey.

    Scotch = FAKE…..

    ReplyDelete
  18. This list is very random. You need to cite your sources, because some misleading info on here 🤦🏾‍♂️

    ReplyDelete